Koan: Leaving aside Tokusan and Gyoho's Blows, how do you use your stick?
Returning to the two koan axioms, me and now, I wonder about the clever answer. And what about the second guessing? Would a better person have used the stick for a friend in need? It quickly could become a rabbit hole.
Case 14 of the Blue Cliff record gives another answer: A monk asked Yunmen, “What is the teaching of an entire lifetime?”
Yunmen said, “An appropriate statement.” (others say, "An appropriate response.")
In that light, I see myself holding the stick, like a policeman with his baton in his belt, ready for whatever might be next.
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Saturday, November 14, 2026
Blows
Koan: Thirty blows of Takusan. Answering, 30 blows. Not answering, 30 blows.
A true dilemma that seems like Sophie's Choice: there is no good choice when deciding which of your children should live. No amount of clever thinking can avoid the blows.
But I keep trying to figure it out. How can I avoid sickness, old age, and death? My sisters and I had a frank discussion once and vowed that “we don't do death.” We thought that if we concentrated on that, we could avoid the inevitable. It didn't work for them.
When learning to be a Japanese potter, you must destroy any perfect pot you throw. The idea is to retain “beginner's mind.” Perhaps the challenge is to renounce the inflated ego when you give the brilliant answer. That's a lot harder than coming up with the right answer.
The “ouch” came just as I finished the drawing. This master was more interested in really teaching us something than in us just giving the “correct” answer. Early on, he had memorized the Diamond Sutra only to be told by an old lady that his efforts were fruitless.
Monday, November 9, 2026
How old is Manjursri Bodhisattva?
Koan: How old is Manjursri Bodhisattva?
In Western schools, at least, we are asked for discrete answers. How many inches are in a foot? We memorize the number and pat ourselves on the back when we raise our hands and answer “correctly.”
Then in Zen, we learn about “not two.” We think we are so smart when we waver between “it depends on the foot” and “the foot is empty so there are no inches.”
Or we might remember that the world is recreated in every moment. So Manjursri is “0.” Or we learn that there is no birth or death. So Manjursri is infinite.
Both of these clever answers are discursive. Again, we are soccer-punched. Remember the two axioms of koans: “me” and “now.” Remember that all that we are is in our heads. How could Manjursri be older than me? It is kind of like the little boy who asks his dad, “When did you start living with Mom and me?” (Imagine Dennis asking that to Mr. and Mrs. Cleaver.) Dad only existed when you were born.
So, how old is Manjursri?
Sunday, November 1, 2026
Big Mind
Koan: Differentiate between the body of Big Mind and the functioning of Big Mind.
Hopefully, we develop an antenna to sometimes not follow directions. It is good to ask, “What assumptions is the questioner making?” If you want to trip someone, you try to catch them “off guard.” This koan does that. Look at the assumptions: that there is a thing called Big Mind, that it has two separate entities—body and functioning—and that differentiating will bring us through "the dharma gate of joyful ease," as Dogen wrote.
I heard the other day, in a meeting of Zen teachers, from a woman who had practice discussions with Suzuki Roshi. She said that he would just have her sit with him and watch her breath. Words have a cost and a benefit. People love to talk. My wife says I talk all day long. Is it time to get the duct tape and start noticing the world?
It is so easy to create a puzzle and then engage people in solving it. And actually this might well be the activity of small mind, as Wordsworth wrote,
“The world is too much with us; late and soon,
Getting and spending, we lay waste our powers...”
We are tested over and over again, as Odysseus was tested by the Sirens. He knew his weakness. That's wisdom. Why did Buddha have to be the attendant to 500 Buddhas before being Buddha himself? Why do the Dalai Lama and other masters need to sit for hours every day? Why is this seemingly simple practice so challenging?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Stick
Koan: Leaving aside Tokusan and Gyoho's Blows, how do you use your stick? Returning to the two koan axioms, me and now, I wonder about ...
-
Some have asked how to post a comment on a blog. The secret is to click on the word "comments" which is circled in red above. ...
-
I heard these sentiments in some recent health care discussions: •Everyone has the right to healthcare. •America is way behind other countri...
-
Kate asked if sounding like Karl Marx is good or bad. I've been thinking about that. And Mr. Obama will be talking tonight about how he ...


